All articles
Employee Benefits

HRA Employee Solutions: A Retention Scorecard

WHIA Team 10 min read
A Washington employer at a sunlit table with a closed navy benefits folder, a stethoscope, and a coffee mug

An HRA only helps retention when employees can use it. HRA employee solutions are the employer-funded allowances, rules, and support that sit next to medical coverage. A higher allowance is not proof that people stayed. Washington employers need a scorecard that connects participation, feedback, and retention signals without pretending the allowance caused the outcome.

Call Washington Health Insurance Agency (WHIA) at 360-464-1622

What Are HRA Employee Solutions for a Washington Employer?

A health reimbursement arrangement is an employer-funded account. The company sets the allowance and the rules. Employees are reimbursed for eligible medical costs, and in some designs for individual premiums. The money is not theirs to spend freely, and unused funds generally stay with the employer.

That is the solution employees actually feel: a known dollar amount, a clear list of what it pays, and a person who answers when a claim stalls. It is not a new network and it is not a replacement for the medical plan unless the design says so.

For a Washington company of about 10 to 200 employees, skip the broad question of whether to offer an HRA. Ask which problem this allowance is supposed to solve for the people you are trying to keep. Budget predictability, help with a high deductible, and premium help on individual coverage are three different jobs. A scorecard built for one of them will misread the others.

The IRS describes the 2019 final rules that let certain HRAs integrate with individual coverage or Medicare, and that recognize a limited excepted-benefit HRA. Design limits change by plan year. The excepted-benefit HRA cap for plan years beginning in 2026 is $2,200 of newly available funds, under Revenue Procedure 2025-19. Confirm the current figure with your tax advisor before you publish an allowance.

WHIA is a Tumwater-based boutique advisory firm, founded in November 2009. We work with Washington small groups on a flat fee, not a commission that rises when the premium does. Employers we work with save an average of 29%, often while keeping the same doctors and the same networks. An HRA is one design tool in that work, not the whole strategy.

Why Can't a Higher Allowance Prove People Stayed?

Retention has too many causes for one benefit to own it. Pay, the manager, the schedule, and a competitor's offer all move voluntary turnover. An HRA can support a decision to stay. It cannot be credited for it from a single before-and-after number.

Three mistakes show up often:

  • Treating enrollment as loyalty. Someone can enroll because the form was pre-checked and still leave in March.
  • Treating a quiet inbox as success. Silence can mean the benefit works. It can also mean people gave up on the claim form.
  • Comparing this year to last year with no other change noted. A wage increase, a layoff, or a new manager will swamp anything the allowance did.

SHRM's 2025 Employee Benefits Survey executive summary reports that 88% of organizations rated health care benefits as extremely or very important. Importance is not the same as proof. Use that as context for why the medical offer matters, then measure your own plan.

A fair scorecard asks a smaller question. Among people who were eligible, did the HRA get used as designed, did employees understand it, and did voluntary turnover in that group move in a way you can explain? If you cannot explain it, say the signals are mixed. Do not publish a savings or retention guarantee you cannot source. WHIA does not publish a dollar-savings promise, and this scorecard should not either.

Which Signals Belong on an HRA Retention Scorecard?

Keep the scorecard to signals you already collect or can collect without a new system. Four is enough. More than that becomes a report nobody reads.

SignalWhat to countWhat a healthy reading looks likeWhat it does not prove
Participation.Eligible employees who enrolled, divided by eligible employees, for that HRA only.Stable or rising versus your own prior enrollment, with the eligible group defined the same way.It does not prove satisfaction, affordability, or that anyone stayed.
Reimbursement use.Share of enrolled employees with at least one paid claim in the plan year, plus the median amount paid.Use that matches the benefit you described at enrollment, not a pile of denied claims.It does not prove that a low balance means the allowance was too small.
Employee feedback.A short pulse after enrollment and again before renewal.Most enrolled employees can state the allowance and name one expense it covers.It does not prove a culture score, or a reason to add a new benefit line.
Retention signal.Voluntary exits among HRA-eligible employees, by job class, compared with the prior plan year.A note next to any swing that names pay, management, or hiring changes in that class.It does not prove that the HRA caused people to stay or to leave.

Read the four together. High participation and almost no paid claims often means the form was easy and the benefit was not. Paid claims plus employees who cannot name the allowance means the back office works and the story at enrollment did not. A drop in voluntary exits means nothing until someone writes down what else changed.

Participation math is its own topic. If you need the formula and the traps in offer rate versus eligibility, use the employee benefits participation rate guide and then come back to the other three signals. Do not stop at enrollment.

How Should You Separate the HRA From the Rest of the Benefits Offer?

Employees rarely experience an HRA as a standalone product. They experience a deductible, a premium, and a reimbursement that may or may not show up. If you score "benefits" as one blob, you will "fix" the wrong piece.

Split the review into three layers:

  1. The core medical plan. Network, deductible, and what people pay at the pharmacy. Continuity of that plan year to year is a different decision from whether people stay at the company.
  2. The HRA allowance. Who is eligible, the annual or monthly amount, which expenses qualify, and how fast a clean claim is paid.
  3. The rest of the offer. Dental, vision, disability, leave, and pay. A retention problem that shows up in exit interviews as "pay" will not move because you raised an HRA by $200.

WHIA's work with Washington employers usually starts at renewal, when the increase is already on the table. The scorecard belongs in that same meeting. Bring last year's four signals next to this year's renewal, and decide whether the allowance still matches the plan you are keeping or changing.

If you are still choosing a design, the type list is a separate decision. ICHRA, QSEHRA, an integrated HRA, and an excepted-benefit HRA answer different eligibility questions. Read the practical guide to HRA types for that choice, then score the one you actually run. This page will not walk through setup steps or plan-document language.

How Do You Read a Weak Score Without Blaming the Allowance?

A weak row is a prompt, not a verdict. Match the pattern to the fix.

People are eligible and still do not enroll

Look at timing and class first. A new hire who starts the month after open enrollment may never see the offer. A class excluded by the plan document is not a communication failure. If eligible people opted out, ask whether the allowance was smaller than the premium they would have to buy, or whether a spouse's plan was simply better.

People enroll and claims sit

This is an administration problem. Count days from a complete claim to payment, and count denials by reason. A denial spike for "not eligible" usually means the expense list in the employee guide does not match the plan. Fix the guide or the design. Do not add a larger allowance to hide a slow process.

Claims get paid and people still leave

Read the exit notes for that job class before you touch the HRA. If the notes say schedule, manager, or pay, say so in the scorecard and leave the allowance alone. If the notes say "I never understood what this paid for," the fix is a one-page explanation at hire and again before renewal, not a new plan type.

WHIA keeps the account-manager load low on purpose so an employee can call a person who already knows the group, rather than a call center. That only helps retention if employees know the number exists. Put the contact on the same one-pager as the allowance.

When Should the Scorecard Change the HRA Design?

Change the design only when the same weak signal shows up for two enrollment cycles. Also change it when one cycle is bad enough that employees pay out of pocket for expenses you told them were covered.

These are reasonable changes. Each one needs the signal next to it.

  • Raise or retarget the allowance when enrolled employees use it, name it correctly, and still say the amount does not cover the deductible you attached it to.
  • Narrow eligible expenses when claims are paying for items leadership did not mean to fund and the retention signal is flat.
  • Fix a class or waiting period when participation is high in one group and near zero in another for a reason the plan document created.
  • Leave the dollar amount and rewrite the explanation when feedback shows people cannot state the allowance, even though claims are paying.

Do not switch HRA types because one year of turnover moved. Type changes reset notices, eligibility, and what the employee has to buy. That is a strategy decision. A readiness review, like the one in WHIA's HRA readiness guide, belongs before a switch, not after a single bad quarter.

Employers in the 10-to-200 range, including the manufacturers, trades, professional firms, nonprofits, and trucking companies WHIA advises, often have one or two job classes that dominate turnover. Score those classes on their own row. A company-wide average will hide the only group the HRA was supposed to help.

What Should You Review Before Renewal?

Set one meeting 60 days before the renewal date. Bring finance, the person who answers employee questions, and whoever owns the plan document. One page is the whole agenda.

  1. Write the eligible headcount and the enrolled headcount. Use the same definition as last year.
  2. Write the share of enrolled employees with a paid claim, the median amount paid, and the top two denial reasons.
  3. Paste three comments from the pulse survey, including one that is unhappy.
  4. Write voluntary exits in the eligible group and one sentence on what else changed (pay, staffing, leadership).
  5. Decide one action: hold, retarget the allowance, fix communication, or review design. Record the owner and the date.

That page is the record you will wish you had next year. It also keeps the renewal conversation from collapsing into "rates are up everywhere." WHIA's clients see that line often. The scorecard gives you something more specific to put next to it.

If the medical plan itself is the retention issue, handle that on its own. The Washington retention playbook covers the broader benefits offer. Health plan retention covers whether to keep the same plan. Neither replaces the four-row HRA scorecard.

For the groups WHIA serves across Washington, the practical next step is a look at how the current allowance sits beside the small-group medical plan, not a new brochure. Bring last year's four signals to that conversation.

A clinician and an employer reviewing health plan documents at a small conference table
Review the HRA next to the medical plan, not as a separate promise.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do HRA employee solutions replace the group medical plan?

Not by default. Some designs reimburse expenses under a group plan the employer still offers. Others, such as an individual coverage HRA, require the employee to have individual coverage. Read the plan you have. Do not assume the allowance is the medical plan.

How is HRA participation different from retention?

Participation is the share of eligible employees who enrolled. Retention is whether those people, or the broader eligible group, stayed employed. You can have full enrollment and rising turnover, or modest enrollment and a stable team. Track them in separate rows.

What if almost nobody files a claim?

Find out whether employees know the allowance, whether the expense list matches real bills, and whether claims are being denied or delayed. Low use with high understanding can mean the allowance is larger than people needed. Low use with low understanding is a communication problem.

Can we say the HRA improved retention in a recruiting post?

Only if you can show the method and you do not claim the allowance was the cause. A sentence such as "voluntary exits in the eligible group were flat while we paid claims for most enrolled employees" is fair. "Our HRA cut turnover 20%" is not, unless a real analysis supports it.

How often should a Washington employer rescore the HRA?

Once before renewal is enough for most groups of 10 to 200 employees. Add a short pulse after open enrollment if you changed the allowance, the eligible class, or the expense list. Rescoring every month creates noise, not a better decision.

Talk with WHIA at 360-464-1622 before you reset the allowance

Ready to Score Your HRA Before Renewal?

Bring the four numbers: who enrolled, who was reimbursed, what employees said, and who left. Washington Health Insurance Agency (WHIA) will help you read them against the medical plan you already have, without treating a single benefit as the reason people stay.

Call 360-464-1622 or book a conversation. We work with Washington employers on a flat fee, and we would rather hold an allowance that employees understand than sell a larger one nobody uses.

Book a conversation with WHIA

From Reading to Talking

Insight is useful. A conversation is better.

Reading about the options is a fine start — but the real value comes from applying them to your plan. Book a thirty-minute conversation and we'll diagnose before we prescribe, with your numbers in front of us.

Book a conversation
Washington employers · 10–200 employees